The first post home was planned to be located at 36 West Main Street, but that didn't come to be. The December 19, 1922 edition of the Asbury Park Press reported that "The Freehold American Legion received a severe setback when recently informed that the erection of a new hall at 36 West Main Street had been changed and instead a new theater will be built by Snider and Son, owners of the lot."

The same article also stated "In order to see Freehold on the court in a home game county seat basketball lovers must wait about six or eight weeks until the new hall, owned by Charles Mount at Throckmorton Street, will be completed."

View more history for Post 54 in Freehold, New Jersey